Colington Pizza in Kill Devil Hills

Colington Pizza in Kill Devil Hills
4.5 / 5
50 reviews

100 Colingwood Ln, Kill Devil Hills, NC 27948-8502, Kill Devil Hills

Overview

Cuisine
  • Pizza
Features
  • Delivery
  • Takeout
  • Seating
  • Waitstaff
  • Wheelchair Accessible
  • Serves Alcohol
Good for
  • Kids
  • Families witd children

Restaurant Hours

Monday

Closed

Tuesday

4:00 pm

Thursday

4:00 pm

Saturday

4:00 pm

Do you deliver ?

Yes use them slot

Review

Add rating restaurant:
Colington Pizza
ML
Mrs Lee
google
11.21.2024
5/5

Highly recommend! Get the garlic knots and the meat lovers pizza!

Colington Pizza
MC
Michael Cocchia
google
10.26.2018
2/5

Sign said best pizza on the inland Apparently they've never ate real pizza I found it a step above frozen pizza which is not that good

Colington Pizza
MF
Matt Farris
google
09.19.2018
4/5

Good solid pizza. Fresh and tasty. Worth the travel out to the island where its located.

Colington Pizza
ps
pat sanders
google
09.08.2018
5/5

Wonderful food. Great staff and friendly atmosphere. Best pizza in OBX

Colington Pizza
EA
Edward Ash
google
08.27.2018
5/5

We always make it a tradition to order from here the 1st evening of our vacation. Awesome pizza! And a large variety to choose from.

Colington Pizza
LH
Laurie Hanchar
google
08.22.2018
5/5

So today I visited and ordered for the first time. Lucky for me the tale of a BLT pizza was true and I had that little slice of heaven w in 15 minutes. It was delicious. Toppings were fresh♩🎤🎶🎶, sorry that's my taste buds singing! The staff was courteous and saved me from giving the PAC MAN machine, original sit down machine , my money by prompt service! I'll be headed back for another taste adventure tomorrow. So do yourself a flavor favor and order pizza here

Colington Pizza
WW
Wyatt Williams
google
07.05.2018
5/5

One the best pizzas I've ever had! 2nd favorite pizza shop in the world! Best pizza on the banks!

Colington Pizza
TL
T L
google
06.26.2018
4/5

Very friendly place with very good pizza. I liked the pizza and the choice of toppings for my custom pie. I would like to try other items on the menu next time.

Colington Pizza
WL
Wendy Lial
google
06.15.2018
5/5

Great Pizza! So glad we took a chance on the local place! Quick delivery, respectfully wore a mask and distanced himself. Pizza was so yummy we had them deliver another pie. We had the meatlovers, pepperoni and a white pizza

Colington Pizza
kt
kevin taylor
google
05.07.2018
5/5

Great pizza place

Colington Pizza
DB
Doug Baer
google
04.15.2018
5/5

Excellent service as there was only one server on a Friday night. Place was packed, but good pie. Like the variety to choose from. Local place that is a hidden favorite.

Colington Pizza
BO
Bryce O'neal
google
04.07.2018
5/5

Really good pie, and service

Colington Pizza
SM
Sy Moody
google
03.21.2018
5/5

BEST pizza in the OBX PERIOD!!!

Colington Pizza
KB
Kyle Burgess
google
03.01.2018
5/5

Best pizza on the island with the best service I have ever seen 10/10 recommend

Colington Pizza
DE
Dean Eich
google
02.15.2018
5/5

One of my favorite places on the Outer Banks. Best Pizza by far. Prices are good and staff are friendly and courteous.

Colington Pizza
GY
GalaxyBunny87 YT
google
02.15.2018
5/5

This place has a sign that says BEST OF THE BEACH for a reason!!!! We ordered here twice during our week stay! Pizza and subs were outstanding! Highly recommend the Collington Luau! Salads were fresh and crisp! Service was fast and friendly!!!!

Colington Pizza
CS
Cindy Swoope
google
02.12.2018
5/5

The most unique and delicious pizzas!All kinds of variety that is just so so WOW and off the hook delicious! They've won Best of the Beach Pizza for the OBX of NC!I highly recommend this place and eat here often. Their wings are delish too! You can get variety of flavored wings. They've got salads, subs, garlic knots, extra spice if ya want.They serve adult beverages and do deliver too!

Colington Pizza
NotAbread
google
02.12.2018
1/5

I waited over an hour and a half for a pizza to arrive. I had been told the pizza would arrive within 45 minutes, IE I waited double the time for my pizza to arrive. After I called back an hour and a half later, they said, “actually, we do not deliver to that street”. Why in the world would it take an hour and a half to find that out? i called back to see if we could get refunded and they kept hanging up on me. Insane.

Colington Pizza
JA
Jesse Argenziano
google
11.24.2017
4/5

Wonderful and historical place to visit. We went in April and unfortunately the house was closed, but the views are beautiful. other people were friendly, inviting, bathrooms were clean, and great conch-finding along the shore!

Colington Pizza
JW
Jacob Williams
google
10.06.2017
4/5

Here while visiting, good service and nice aesthetic.

Colington Pizza
CB
Cathy Bender
google
10.05.2017
5/5

Great salads. Excellent pizza. Tasty wine. Fast service.

Colington Pizza
EB
Eric Barna
google
10.03.2017
5/5

Fantastic pizza! I come here every time I come down here

Colington Pizza
BB
Brian Burgess
google
09.26.2017
5/5

Quality food, attentive staff, fair prices

Colington Pizza
BZ
Bethany Zitzmann
google
09.07.2017
4/5

Good pizza, good price, faster than most of the places on the beach. Only reason I took off a star is they don’t seem to have call waiting, so if someone else is on the line you just have to keep calling back until the line is clear.

Colington Pizza
JO
Jay Osborne
google
08.24.2017
5/5

Great toppings and fast delivery. Best pie on the island

Colington Pizza
SL
Sinead Lockhart
google
07.25.2017
5/5

Best pizza on the OBX! This boutique pizza shop will surely charm you with it's stuffed mushrooms, fancy pies, delicious brownie a la mode, and, of course, it's healthy dose of southern hospitality. They're open from 4-10 pm and won't deliver past "the airstrip" but if you're on the OBX and are looking for a local favorite, you have to try this place out!

Colington Pizza
Marcus
google
07.13.2017
4/5

Pizza was fantastic! Nice family run restaurant that deserves support. Had a pepperoni and white pizza, both were delicious. Only negative thing I have, I ordered the garlic Rosemary knots and they were ridiculous tiny! Make those bigger and fluffier and you've got 5 stars!

Colington Pizza
AE
Aaron Evans
google
07.05.2017
5/5

Best pizza in OBX

Colington Pizza
JG
Jerry Gebhart
google
05.12.2017
5/5

The best pizza ever!

Colington Pizza
DB
Dawn Butcher
google
05.06.2017
5/5

Locally owned and operated. Our only pizza place on Colington Island. Yet, we are so thankful to have one that is not a franchise. They offer delivery or dine in and have a bar as well.

Colington Pizza
KJ
Kevin Johnson
google
04.17.2017
5/5

We have been coming here for years. Great food and a fun place. The staff is as good or better than the food!!!! Cold beer too. Best pizza on the beach.

Colington Pizza
HD
Heather DeFrancesco
google
04.06.2017
2/5

Overpriced & overrated. Not impressed with the "best pizza on the beach".

Colington Pizza
PK
Polangie K
google
01.26.2017
5/5

Found this great place while out on a drive. This delicious gem is a little off the main road but sooo worth the drive. Very friendly gentleman behind the bar! We ordered the shiffletti pizza and it was incredible!! They put a pizza spin on the always popular Italian sandwich and truly delicious!! We thoroughly enjoyed and will be back soon to enjoy it again!!!

Colington Pizza
AS
Adan Sanches
google
11.19.2016
4/5

This was the first time my family and myself tried Colington’s out. We love to support family owned as well as independent businesses because that’s just the right thing to do. That being said, the ordering was made easy by their system of curbside pick-up. The food itself was average and was a bit too thin in certain areas, which slightly over cooked to a hard crisp. I recommend; however, know that you aren’t eating a “pedigree pizza.”

Colington Pizza
PF
Patrick Finger
google
11.01.2016
5/5

Great pizza! Perfect crunch and not any of that floppy pizza you get elsewhere. Good beer selection too! -Go Hokies

Colington Pizza
AA
Arman Analouei
google
09.24.2016
4/5

Lovely pizza. Great service.

Colington Pizza
ZS
Zen Sickler
google
09.16.2016
5/5

Colington's best for sure. Great pizza, plenty of options on the menu and all at a good price. Very kind staff, too.

Colington Pizza
HE
Heather Ericsson
google
08.22.2016
5/5

Love this place, all the food is good. All the time

Colington Pizza
JJ
Jenna June
google
07.27.2016
3/5

Decent pizza place, friendly service, but average pizza. Nothing out of the ordinary.

Colington Pizza
KB
Kim Burgess
google
07.16.2016
5/5

Delicious food. AMAZING SERVICE!

Colington Pizza
DP
David Pohlit
google
07.12.2016
3/5

I have been a patron of this fine place for about 3 years. Never an issue. Great pizza, friendly atmosphere, and reasonable pricing. Since Covid came about, it seems things have changed. I don't know if personnel changed but the last few times I have ordered (I pick up) the pizza has been burnt, it also seems like it has been lying around. Today I ordered a simple large pepperoni with EXTRA cheese. The pizza was paper thin, burnt and hardly any cheese. I always tip at least 20% plus even when picking up. What is the deal?

Colington Pizza
JY
Jeff Y
google
07.11.2016
5/5

Great pizza, and Loretta always does an awesome job

Colington Pizza
PT
Pam Thomas
google
05.24.2016
5/5

Our favorite pizza place.

Colington Pizza
MG
Mancil Gray
google
05.05.2016
5/5

I love the baked wings and PBR on tap. Pizza is awesome and the staff is friendly.

Colington Pizza
CV
Chris Varney
google
04.18.2016
2/5

Not the best...but got the job done. I would suggest more sauce and more cheese. Everything was just a bit bland. Great folks to deal with though.

Colington Pizza
MS
Mark Smith
google
04.07.2016
5/5

Colington pizza is a really good place to try. Everything I've eaten there is tasty and pretty unique.

Colington Pizza
YP
Yvonne Pritchard
google
03.22.2016
5/5

Great pizza and service

Colington Pizza
DJ
Daniel J. Hossack
google
02.18.2016
5/5

Awesome Pizza always good

Colington Pizza
WS
Warren Sawyer
google
01.26.2016
5/5

Delicious pizza. Good service

Colington Pizza
BC
Beach Cooler
google
01.10.2016
4/5

Always good and fresh. Best stuffed mushrooms on the beach hands down.

Your question has been sent.

Expect an answer!

Thank!

Your review has been submitted.

Order food

Reservation

Want to order over the phone?

Call 12524413339

Thank you for being with us!

We will call you back!